About Us









First National Insurance Services, Inc. is an independent insurance agency serving the Southern Illinois area.  All our staff are licensed professional insurance agents.  We strive to provide the very best customer service possible.

We represent a number of highly rated insurance companies that are able to offer top quality coverage with competitive rates. 

Contact us today to help you get the insurance coverage you need to protect yourself and your family from an unexpected claim.

Office Hours:  Monday – Friday 8:15-5:00 

Peggy Sims

Vice President & Manager

Peggy can help you with business, commercial, life and medical insurance policies to make sure you have the coverage you need.  Insurance can be confusing and she can help you through the process by answering any questions you may have.

Peggy also oversees the day-to-day operations of the agency to make sure only the best insurance companies are represented.  

“I love being involved in my community”, says Peggy.  She currently serves on the Board of Directors for the Pinckneyville Chamber of Commerce as secretary.  She is also on the Board of Directors for the First National Bank in Pinckneyville.  In the past she has been President of the Pinckneyville Community High School Education Foundation, served on the Pinckneyville Strategic Planning Committee and was Outstanding Person of the Year in 2000. 

She and her husband David reside in rural Pinckneyville.

Jennifer Wright

Property and Casualty

Jennifer is ready to assist you with your home, auto, recreation vehicle or life insurance needs. She will carefully review your requests with each carrier and provide fast and accurate quotes. Insurance can be confusing and intimidating. Let Jennifer take away that stress by doing all of the work for you.

Jennifer resides in Pinckneyville with her husband Matt and two children. She and her family are heavily involved in the community and Jennifer serves as a board member to the Chamber of Commerce and PCHS Education Foundation.

Allyssa Agnew

Property & Casualty Sales/Customer Care Specialist

Families change, vehicles change and your preferred coverage may change.  So if you find yourself needing to make a change to your policy, Allyssa can help.  Do you need to make a payment?  Call her and she can assist you.   She strives for customer satisfaction. She is also our agencies claim specialist and can assist you with filing your claim.  Call or stop by our office today and speak to Allyssa about your insurance needs.

Allyssa resides in Pinckneyville with her husband Adam and family.  She loves playing on a summer softball league and watching her kids follow in her footsteps, playing in their own summer leagues.  She likes to take random small trips with her family.